CyberDefenders is an independently funded nonprofit project.. Donate

Mastering Python Code Reviews

A Comprehensive Guide to Python Code Review for Students

Conducting code reviews for students is essential for their development and understanding of programming practices. In this guide, we’ll explore the guidelines, best practices, a review template, and free tools that can assist in reviewing Python code for students.

Guidelines and Best Practices

1. Understand the Requirements

2. Check for Readability

3. Evaluate the Efficiency

4. Look for Modularity

5. Ensure Proper Commenting

6. Test the Code

7. Encourage Best Practices

8. Provide Constructive Feedback

Code Review Template

Here’s a template that can be used to structure feedback:

Code Review for [Student’s Name]

  1. Requirements:
    • Meets all requirements
    • Handles edge cases
    • Comments: ________________
  2. Readability:
    • Clear naming
    • Proper indentation
    • Comments: ________________
  3. Efficiency:
    • Efficient algorithm
    • Comments: ________________
  4. Modularity:
    • Proper use of functions/classes
    • Comments: ________________
  5. Commenting:
    • Sufficient comments
    • Comments: ________________
  6. Testing:
    • Code works as intended
    • Comments: ________________
  7. Best Practices:
    • Follows Pythonic constructs
    • Comments: ________________
  8. General Feedback: ____________________

Free Tools for Code Review

  1. PyLint: A tool that checks the code for compliance with PEP 8 standards.
  2. Flake8: Combines PyFlakes, pycodestyle, and McCabe complexity checking.
  3. Bandit: A tool for finding common security issues in Python code.
  4. An online IDE that allows collaborative code reviews.

By following these guidelines, using the template, and incorporating these tools, you’ll be able to provide comprehensive, constructive, and consistent code reviews to your students. It will not only help them improve their coding skills but also encourage a positive and engaging learning experience.